| Argumentation | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 No "claims" or "warrants" (no use of evidence or data from BioBLAST!™) |
2 Few claims and warrants (not necessarily supported by evidence or data). |
3 Some claims are warranted (sometimes supported by evidence or data). |
4 Most claims warranted (consistent use of evidence or data). |
5 All claims warranted (always use evidence or data from BioBLAST! or elsewhere). |
| Engagement | ||||
| 1 Group is unfocused; unclear goals. |
2 Group is somewhat focused some of the time. |
3 Group is focused some of the time; goals are clear but not always achieved. |
4 Some members of the group are focused most of the time. |
5 Whole group is focused all of the time; goals are met. |
| Turn-Taking | ||||
| 1 No teamwork. Nobody contributes to discussion. |
2 A little teamwork some of the time (but maybe one individual talks too much or one doesn't talk enough). |
3 Some teamwork, but not all group members participate. |
4 A lot of teamwork where most members participate most of the time. |
5 Teamwork and participation are high; everyone has a voice; their ideas are heard. |