Minutes of the DLS: June 7, 1996

 

Opening his eyes, Howard Hodgins saw the light for the first time in quite a long time, if not for the first time in his life.  It was bright, and moving, and seemed to be calling to him... "Howard! Howard! Get up off the floor, you little redheaded rat!"  Assured by the last comment that he was not on his way to see Jesus (although his personal history should have been enough for that) Howard sat up on the floor of the lower chamber and squinted into the flashlight. 

"Who is that?"  he said in his usual calm manner, "Why am I here?" 

"Hell if I know," said our beloved President, "you've been here ever since the night of our last meeting in the Spring.  Didn't I tell you not to go out drinking with Andrew?" 

Incredulous, Howard looked at his clothes and sure enough, he was still wearing the same suit (the one he said was an Armani but all of us knew better) cufflinks and all. 

"Wow!  That was some hangover!" 

"Yeah, that's what the carpet said -- and has been saying for about 2 months.  Becky decided to go ahead and clean up your mess after the second week.  She tried to wake you, but you wouldn't budge." 

"You mean the lovely Ms. Richie, the light of my life, the passion of my days had to clean up my puke?  She touched me in my sleep, and I wasn't conscious to realize it?!  My existence is meaningless now -- please let me go."

But as Howard rose from the deep stain in the carpet, Madame President, pushed him back down. "Not so fast, buster," she said in a sinister tone. "Now I'm the light of your life, and you just have to deal with it -- starting now!"

For the first time, Howard noticed that the lovely Ms. Polentz was not clad in her usual attire.  Instead, she wore an outfit more becoming of a dominatrix, complete with leather strapping and whip.  The important parts were covered, though, and after seeing this in front of him, Howard made sure his were too.

"Uh, I don't know quite what you mean..."

"Well," said our leather-bound Bethany, "all the women in the Society decided that whoever was able to wake you up would have the privilege of you as their slave -- it gets you out of the $5,125 in fines you've accumulated during your stay in the Hall."  I've been here for 4 weeks trying to get you for myself -- Rachel was here before me, but she gave up when all she could elicit from you after 5 weeks was a burp."

"I never agreed to this!  I don't think this is allowable under the Constitution!  Isn't there a sexual harassment clause or something?"  Howard was desperate now.

"Nah, you and Andrew took a stand against that in the committee and got it taken out.  That was OK with me, though -- thanks for giving me this wonderful opportunity!  Don't worry, honey, I won't hurt your little red head a bit -- we're just going to have a little fun!"

 

The meeting was called to order at 7:35.  The minutes of both the previous regular meeting and the Special Constitutional Meeting were read and approved by the Society with minor changes.  There was one first time guest and no second or third time guests.  Three alums, Ms. K. Polentz, Mr. Fitzgerald, and Mr. Deriso joined the Society this evening. 

 

The Society entered Programs, where Mr. Deriso took the floor and presented, at long last, the scrapbook for the year and some odd months that he served the Society as Historian.

 

Then began the annual tradition of farewell addresses, given by members departing the Society due to graduation.  The first to speak was Ms. Clark, who opened her speech by saying that the debate brought her to Demosthenian, but that it was the people that kept her here.  Among other bits of wisdom, Ms. Clark observed that strong people would always try to mold the world around them to fit their worldview. Speaking with only veiled reference to Demosthenian, she suggested that it is worthwhile for all of us to accommodate people's differences.  She also told us that "good music is better when it's loud," "life is too short to drink cheap beer," and to "make time to share with people you care about."  She read the poem, "Politics" to the Society and gave her comments on it.  She also gave Things We Carry, a collection of short stories, to the Society's library.

 

Next to speak was Mr. Gasaway, who spoke mostly about his first interactions with members of the Society.  His first experience was a party at Apt. 74, where he spoke with Mr. Choi.  He also remembered his first visit to a meeting and listened to Mr. Trammell tell guests why the Heap was so inferior.  Mr. Gasaway mentioned that the night he joined was also his 21st birthday, and that his maiden address was about something from class that day (a trend that developed in his speeches from then on).  He reminded us all of his infamous "Integrity" speech from his first Sgt. At Arms race  His evaluation of his time in the Society was that speaking gave him confidence, the Society gave him great friends, and the key to the Hall was a key to knowledge.  His message to us all: "Putting a little guy in with giants will always raise him up."

Mr. Gasaway gave the book, Tao: The Watercourse Way to the library.

 

Ms. Spornberger rose to give her second farewell address in as many years, and she thanked us for the chance to do it all again.  She said that while she had been a member of both societies and relished the literary society experience, she said she was a lot more grown-up as a Demosthenian.  Among other things, Ms. Spornberger credited the Society with changing the way she communicates, and made her wish that all exams were oral.  While she would not give herself credit as a student, she said that most of her learning had come in this Hall and in life.  She left Demosthenians with many words of advice, among them: "be willing to say what you really think and stand by it, no matter the offense," "keep Demosthenian in perspective," and "maintain who you are, both as people and as a Society."  She gave to the Society a copy of C.S. Lewis' The Screwtape Letters and a USAir timetable.

 

Ms. Sullivan spoke first about why she came to Demosthenian.  After a not-so-surprisingly bad experience at the Heap, she was invited to Demosthenian by Ms. Tomlinson and found it a welcome change from the sexual harassment of the Heapers (she has not yet seen that side of our President, I suppose).  She said she had always enjoyed debating and spoke about asthma and smoking in her maiden address.  As far as what she learned here, Ms. Sullivan said that you must be willing to back away sometimes to avoid being frustrated.  Also, she echoed Ms. Spornberger's sentiments, saying that you must always stand for what you believe.  Ms. Sullivan left us with these words of wisdom: "If you don't like it here, leave!"  She gave keys to the Hall to Ms. B. Richie, Ms. Tomlinson, Mr. Sirak, and Ms. Polentz.  She also handed down the traditional dancing boots to Ms. J. Richie, complete with spray paint.

 

Mr. Meaders spoke next, saying from the start that he would not try to act as if her was an active member.  He described himself as not an eloquent speaker, and said that he often did not know what to say.  However, Mr. Meaders told the Society it had given him a better idea about how to go about speaking, and that he plans to start a Demosthenian Union in the school where he teaches.  While he tries to spread the art of debate in the world, Mr. Meaders entreated the Society to keep Demosthenian alive and well here on campus.  He asked us to remember him as one who loved the Society, and gave his key to the Hall to a younger member who he said epitomized that love to him, Mr. Hodgins (he's not the only one who thinks that, apparently!)

 

Mr. Merritt, recently deposed from the bench, said that he was happy with the Society and his personal accomplishments as a member.  He hoped that all of those present would get as much from Demosthenian as he had.  In his time here, Mr. Merritt said he noticed first the history, then the debate, and asked us to maintain both with equal vigor.  In his usual direct style, Mr. Merritt closed saying that through it all, it had been an honor to be a Demosthenian, and that you should live your life and never look back.  He gave keys to Mr. Hodgins, Mr. Shumaker, Ms. Ramirez, and Mr. V-Van M-Meter.

 

Mr. Trammell was the last farewell speaker of the evening, and surprised the Society when he said that the first and last time he stood behind the podium were both intimidating.  Telling us that he had so much to say and that the people here mean so much to him, Mr. Trammell launched into a discussion of the Hall and its powers.  Asking the audience to focus on the yellow walls, he said "this Hall has powers to effect me and all of us -- anger, euphoria, nostalgia -- in so many ways."  He continued with a narrative about why he came to Demosthenian, giving the Society a family history that included a Robert Toombs Trammell as his grandfather, a moral imperative to be a Demosthenian if there ever was one.  Mr. Trammell spoke of the powerful cult of Toombs, speaking to the portrait hanging in the upper chamber and saying that all this history is "echoes, very important."  For what is important, according to Mr. Trammell, is not what we are saying here, which he described as a scratch in time, but that we are saying it, here in this Hall, that is eternal and meaningful.  He spoke of the legacy of Dr. Saye, and that the reverence the members expressed a feeling that all of us should share, and ask ourselves, "How do you want the spirit of Demosthenian to know you?"  Mr. Trammell asked us to model ourselves after Toombs, a man of passion, who believed he was right until the death.  He thanked the Society for allowing him to share the oath with us and to participate in all these traditions and more.  Calling keys a symbol of immortality, Mr. Trammell gave one to Mr. Shumaker, Mr. Hodgins, Mr. Bowman, Mr. Kaiser, Mr. Pyrdum, and Mr. V-Van M-Meter.

 

The Society dried its collective eyes and moved into Committee Reports.  Ms. Ramirez asked members to write their preferences for Fall Quarter committees on a sheet downstairs.  Mr. Smith related to the Society his troubles in retrieving the Society's copy of the Pandora and asked members to return books they had borrowed from the Society before they left for the summer.  Mr. Hortman asked for $100 to be approved as a discretionary summer budget, and for $20 for a banner to hang above the Tate Center plaza.  Both were approved by the Society.  Mr. V-Van M-Meter rose and asked members to complete the phone list in the president's office downstairs.  Mr. Stuart rose to remind the Society of the importance of quorum during the Wall of Fame vote later in the evening, and stressed that the new Constitution is official and would be enforced that evening.

 

The Society then moved into Old Business, and the Wall of Fame resolution was untabled and discussed.  Mr. Meaders, at his first meeting as an alum, rose to support Mr. Darden's candidacy as a member of the Wall of Fame.  He said that Mr. Darden was not only a close family friend, but was also a distinguished public servant in both Cobb County and in the U.S. Congress.  The question was called and Mr. Darden was added to the Wall of Fame by a vote of 12-0. 

 

We moved into New Business, and Mr. Pyrdum took the floor and spoke about closure, a thought that was inspired by the night's farewell addresses and a book he had read, Small Gods.  He presented the following:

 

Be It Resolved: Mortality is man's greatest asset.

 

                                                                        Respectfully submitted,

 

                                                                        Carl S. Pyrdum

 

Mr. Stuart took the floor and agreed with Mr. Pyrdum, saying that he had never seen closure like he did during farewell addresses.  He further stated that distance makes one seem godlike, and that we are all gods unto ourselves, as long as others know you and you know yourself.  Sure, Andrew.

 

Mr. Hortman rose and said that the greatest challenge in life is to become a legend, not to achieve immortality.  He told us that mortality drives us to achieve great things while we have time. 

 

Mr. Hodgins spoke next and said that we all need to die to avoid getting bored.  The limit of death gives us perpetually something to strive for (such as the death of short redheads in Armani suits). 

 

Mr. Bowman said that physical mortality gives great figures, such as the man of the evening Robert Toombs, a motivation to accomplish the things that have made them immortal.

 

Mr. Choi employed the Golden Mean theory to discuss the resolution, saying that we will all reach a peak in our achievement and then decline.  Disputing that anyone is immortal, he still boasted that he was passing his seed along to everyone he came in contact with.  All those in the upper chamber looked frantically for Cheong's seed, but most of us found nothing -- pretty scary!

 

Mr. Garrison rose to disagree with the resolution, bringing up examples such as Richard Nixon and Strom Thurmond who did their best work in their old age.  Instead, mortality serves as our greatest obstacle to accomplishing all we hope to in life.

 

Ms. Ramirez told us about her greatest role model, her grandmother, and mentioned that her personality, not her mortality, was her greatest asset.

 

Mr. V-Van M-Meter identified death as an ulitmate end (duh!) and that ultimate ends give the ultimate perspective on one's accomplishments.  Ironically, this perspective often shows us all the limitless potential of our own lives.

 

The question was called and passed 6-4.

 

Mr. Stuart stepped to the lectern next to object to the weepiness that had infiltrated the Upper Chamber.  Saying that regardless of the end, there is always a beginning on the other side.  Somehow he made a good segue to this resolution:

 

Be It Resolved:  It is not necessarily what you say, but it is necessarily how you say it.

 

                                                            Respectfully,

 

                                                            Andrew H. Stuart

 

Mr. Hortman rose to laud the presenter for his resolution, proclaiming that presentation is everything in speaking.  He said that this resolution explains both why Demosthenian should have lost (and did lose) the annual debate with the Heap, and why Bill Clinton is in the Oval Office.

 

Mr. V-Van M-Meter stormed to the lectern, stating that people who have nothing to say but say nothing well are the source of many of today's problems.  Presentation is important, but our education is supposed to give us the information and ethics to be responsible with that ability to present one's thoughts, and that responsibility is a great one.

 

Mr. Pyrdum entertained us all with an interpretive version of the argument expressed in the resolution.  He said that he "had a dream, that there is a purple crocodile," which Mr. Pyrdum rode across the world and explained the meaning of life to the Society -- and we believed him!  Point taken.

 

Mr. Bowman rose and made a distinction between the resolution describing the present or the resolution presenting the ideal.  He said that that those who follow the message of the resolution are simply pandering to society's weaknesses.

 

Ms. Ramirez somehow introduced the Brickheap Manifesto into the debate, but I'm not sure is she pulled it off or not.  She closed by saying that we cannot completely turn our eyes from the importance of presentation.

 

Mr. Choi, the Golden Mean boy (or is that mean Golden boy?) brought up the preamble of the Society's constitution, which calls on us to achieve both truth and the means to express it.  Saying that the two are inseparable, Mr. Choi said that eloquence can cause the thought to echo in our heads and get the idea across.

 

Mr. Hodgins presented the Society with an illustration of his own about none other than...suits!  He said that the members who wore suits to meetings were listened to more closely -- members were unsure whether this was a comment on gender or dress.  He gave many more examples, but made the jump to Mortal Kombat 3 and Streetfighter, at which time he disproved his point about the worthiness of words spoken by people in suits.

 

The question was then called and the resolution passed 7-3... not a flawless victory.

 

The meeting was adjourned, subject to Mr. Bowman's critic's report, at 11:20.

 

Madame President sauntered toward Hodgins, trailing her whip behind her and grinning from ear to ear.

"I just don't know about this...you mean, you want me to put my pole entz there?" Howard was shaking now.

"Not yet, you little devil! Now let me show you..." But suddenly, Bethany let out a scream, and fell to the ground.  Something heavy had grabbed her and fallen on top of her.  She was being smothered!  Howard was getting away!

"Oh, I'm sorry Bethany.  I didn't recognize you!  Wow, nice outfit.  Where was Howard going?"

"I don't know, Hortman," the President sneered in disgust.  "Why are you here?"

"I guess I've been here since June," Jason said with a look of amazement.  "Wow, Andrew sure can get you drunk can't he?"

"Where were you?  We never saw you here!"

"Oh, I woke up under the Hall -- apparently I just ran right through the stucco when I was trying to impersonate an elephant -- a neat Republican trick I learned.  By the way, it was a rat that died there a while ago -- I met his cousins."

Bethany got up and brushed herself off.  She walked to the door, which stood wide open, and picked up the tie that Howard had dropped during his frantic escape.  Draping it around her neck, she sighed, "I don't have much time left here, but I will get some young Demosthenian meat before I'm through.  Maybe that Shumaker kid will succumb to my seductions..."

 

Until next week, I am your faithful and frightened Secretary,